LINUX.IE, website of the Irish Linux Users' Group
Tux rules!

   
Home
New Users
Articles
::In The News
::Industry
::Interviews
::Reviews
::Tips
::Tutorials
Download
Projects
Community
Vendors

  Print Version
Email to...
 
Archives:


planetILUG

Recent News

News Archive


Join the
ILUG
on FaceBook


Join the
ILUG
on LinkedIn


Join the
ILUG SETI
Group



















 
 :: Articles :: Reviews :: Caldera 2.3 Install Review

24 November 1999

Introduction

OK, this really won't be a total review. Essentially I'll describe the install process in an abbreviated manner. For those of you who want to install Linux for the first time, or if you've used other distributions before and want to know what to expect, this page tries to lay that out. If you want a full review of Caldera, check Google or a Linux magazine like Linux Journal or Linux World.

First I'll describe my setup, then I'll describe the physical aspects of doing the install, and lastly describe each screen in the installation.

The "Hardware"

The hardware is a VMWare Virtual Machine. It should be similar to a real PC, but with one difference (hopefully): So far all Linux installs I've done on a VM have failed to recognise the video card. I don't really find fault with the XFree people or the installation programs - I'd rather they work on getting real cards working first. Each new release and distribution of Linux seems to have more supported cards so it's obvious they're moving forward there.

Otherwise it's a pretty standard setup. A cdrom drive, and a 800m hard disk. The system is set to boot off the floppy, cd, and then the hd. The VM has 32megs of RAM.

The Physical Labor

Put the cd in the cdrom drive, power on! Pretty simple, eh?

The Process

The cdrom drive spins up and a text screen offers a black and white ascii graphic and a blurb on LILO options. It times out quick and boots into a GUI Linux boot process. After the kernel finishes booting you're allowed to pick a language. Obviously I'm one of those english speaking types, so I left it alone and clicked next. The mouse selection screen was interesting. It was here I learned that the install (which seems to use KDE) can be navigated entirely by keyboard. I selected a wheeled 3 button intellimouse since that's what I have physically. But VMWare doesn't translate that and the mouse had a very affinity for the right corner after that - your selection here takes immediate effect! But by using the keyboard that can quickly be adjusted.

The keyboard screen follows a similar paradigm, and just like the mouse screen let's you test your selection. Selecting a mouse wrong leads to pretty dramatic results but selecting a keyboard incorrectly is a little less disasterous. Nevertheless I like this ability to confirm your selection. It is rather amazing just how many types of keyboards and mice there are in the world.

Then we come to the dreaded video card and monitor screens. I haven't tried Caldera on a real machine yet, but it failed to detect whatever card VMWare conjours up. The screen shots are a good demo of what a failed detection brings up. I suspect an a card the installer recognizes, this screen will look far simpler. It's still far better the presenting a new user with vi and /etc/X11/XF86Config! Of course manly men will probably miss it, but the file's still there to be edited with emacs, vi, or cat.

Configuring X still gets under the mainstream nerves, but "disk partitioning" isn't far behind in terms of complaints. There are very sensible reasons to partition disks wisely, but there are also very sensible reasons to make backups - and end users don't tend to do those either. Caldera's disk partitioner is pretty approachable here. And of course after partitioning, one needs to format. I'm pretty lazy on this since it's going to be blown away with another distro soon. One thing to note, I chose to install on the whole disk. I have no idea how dual boot configuration works since I hate rebooting machines - hence my introuction to Linux since I got sick of SCO's pressing need to be rebooted once every few weeks. I still hear people say some users use some legacy OS out of some software outfit in the Nortwestern USA that needs to be rebooted daily. Urban Legends seem to get more outlandish every year I tell ya!

OK, another issue to pay attention to. Linux is a multi-user, multi-tasking OS. It's been that since it's inception, just like it's UNIX godparent. Caldera's install is the first installer I've seen that takes advantage of this. Now VMWare is pretty speedy considering it's task, but the fact that Caldera Linux is already formatting the drive at this stage meant that the VM was getting sluggish. So I accidentally clicked Next twice and thereby accepted a Standard install (which began in the background just like the formatting, though it obviously had to wait for formatting to complete). Anyway, I clicked Back and here's the greyed out version of the package selection screen. Seems simple, but I didn't run through it. Be careful with you mouse clicks!

As mentioned Linux is multi-user, a confusing concept to new users. One person on the net referred to Linux boxes as "Family Computers." Interesting selling point. Caldera seems to put a good face on it as well, and presents a screen for the root user as well as at least one regular user. iThey're serious about that additional non-root user - the next button only pops up once you've added at least one.

Networking is as straight forward as networking goes. I'm sure a new user would still see complexity here, but it's about as easy as ipv4 is going to get. LILO gets similar treatment. Again a new user will probably worry (and don't take my selection as The Right Way To Do It), but like all the other screens the help box on the side tries to explain what's going on.

Time is something almost all of us understand, and Caldera's background install process chugs along well. While it does so the time zone screen is very complete and usable. Once that's complete Caldera's true brillance shines here. Even on the VM performance was adequate for a decent game of tetris. Between the background processing and game at the end I'm very impressed with Caldera's work here. Who said innovation didn't exist in the Linux realm?

Summary

All in all a very quick and simple install. I would have liked to see a video/monitor selection of "what the installer is using cause it seems to work" option. I know the res/dimmensions are poor at install but I couldn't find a decent card/monitor combo in 5 minutes of fiddling with it. If I had I would have shown screen shots of the post install system. Caldera seems to be aiming at end users, and judged on those terms it does quite well. Corel's Linux seems better but then Caldera's 2.3 has been out for months whereas Corel Linux came out last week. For those of you new to the Linux community months might not seem long, but in the Linux world that's a lot of time. I don't follow Caldera's progress but I suspect 2.3/3.0 is probably coming soon and I'm sure it will offer a host of improvements.

Author

kevin@linux.ie. Thanks to Linux Mall for their great cheap distribution source! No thanks to Irish customs for the extra £27 it cost to import...




You may find the following helpful:
VMWare 1.0


About the author, Kevin Lyda.

USERS COMMENTS


                                                                                                    

 

Hosted by HEAnet


Maintained by the ILUG website team. The aim of Linux.ie is to support and help commercial and private users of Linux in Ireland. You can display ILUG news in your own webpages, read backend information to find out how. Networking services kindly provided by HEAnet, server kindly donated by Dell. Linux is a trademark of Linus Torvalds, used with permission. No penguins were harmed in the production or maintenance of this highly praised website. Looking for the Indian Linux Users' Group? Try here. If you've read all this and aren't a lawyer: you should be!
RSS Version
Powered by Dell